• PRO

    Uniforms are held to a specific standard when they are...

    school uniforms

    Uniforms are held to a specific standard when they are given to the school for reuse, just as if you were donating clothes to the needy. Children will not receive uniform that are stained or worn down, they have to be in a moderate shape. Kids at public school wear spandex to school and ill fitting clothing that isn't appropriate to wear to school. If the school isn't strict with their dress code, then children will be able to dress more freely.

    • https://www.debate.org/debates/school-uniforms/78/
  • PRO

    My opponent has not provided carefully scrutinized...

    school uniforms

    My opponent has made several contentions: (1) I am a student, (2) I know uniformed students - I hate them, and (3) uniformed students become so repressed they party too hard when they let loose. My opponent's arguments represent, respectively: (1) an appeal to authority. While my opponent may be a student, he is not necessarily every student, nor does his status as a student confer upon him any special abilities to discern the advantages and disadvantages of uniforms; and (2) & (3) sampling bias. My opponent has not provided carefully scrutinized statistics but rather his own selective sample of a group of uniformed hooligans. These hooligans may not be representative of the entirety of students who wear uniforms. In addition, the earlier mentioned problem with regards to the elimination of raucous parties appears to be no problem at all if the elimination of such parties preserves the safety of the students. I am sure there are some nice uniform-wearing students in the world, Con. You just need to meet them. Perhaps you could don a uniform and approach them in disguise. If they accept you, the uniforms must be working. As an aside, I went to a school that had a uniform and a school that had a dress code (elementary and high school, respectively). I don't know about all of the students, but I was an okay enough individual. Methinks uniforms might not be the cause of the issues of which you complain.

    • https://www.debate.org/debates/school-uniforms/21/
  • PRO

    Now I think we're just arguing the same point. ... All...

    school uniforms

    Now I think we're just arguing the same point. All I'm saying is that unless people start using some common sense in what they wear, school uniforms are going to become a necessity, no matter what kind of school the student goes to, public or private.

    • https://www.debate.org/debates/school-uniforms/1/
  • PRO

    This took place in Long Beach California) Overall, the...

    School uniforms should be required

    "Also, what was the violence like before uniforms? It's not impressive that it dropped 90% if there was little bullying in the first place. " If it dropped 90%, the violence must have had some impact on the school for them to keep track. I have also taken the liberty to pull some more statistics on how much safer and less-violent schools have been with uniforms. (This took place in Long Beach California) Overall, the crime rate dropped by: 91 % School suspensions dropped by: 90 % Sex offenses were reduced by: 96 % Incidents of vandalism went down: 69 % Assaults in grades K-8 decreased by: 85 % (http://www.statisticbrain.com...) Also, bringing back up the topic of cost..(where you are again proven wrong) "Uniforms can cost a lot depending on what school it is" The cost of uniforms is a concern for some families, but it has been shown that families in which the children wear uniforms spend almost 80 dollars less on clothing for their children for the school year compared to those who do not have children who wear uniforms. Also, 44 percent of the families in which the children wear uniforms believe that it keeps the children more focused on school. (http://www.ehow.com...) To conclude, Cited pros of school uniforms include decreased violence in schools and increased discipline of the students. Violence decreases because students are less likely to be picked on for their clothing, as there can be no focus on brand names. Along with this, students who are from poorer families are less likely to feel jealous or ashamed that they do not have the same clothing as those who are from wealthier families. Also, as the children wear the same things, it is difficult, if not impossible, for them to wear gang colors or other types of gang-related items. Discipline among the students increases because any tensions related to fashion or gangs have been lessened and students are more likely to be focused on the learning process.

    • https://www.debate.org/debates/School-uniforms-should-be-required/2/
  • CON

    In schools, some students are poor while others are rich....

    School Uniforms Should not be Required

    School uniforms should be required because they encourage discipline, help students resist peer pressure to buy new clothes, and diminish economic and social barriers between students. First of all, school uniforms encourage discipline by making students focus on studying and homework rather than new clothes. In the morning, instead of worrying on different outfits, students can do school related activities like organizing their backpack, double-checking their homework, or studying. Students spend a lot of time thinking about clothing, but now, since they have uniforms, they no longer have to go through tedious shopping or hours of decisions of what to wear. School uniforms also help students resist the urge to buy designer clothing. When everyone is wearing the same uniform, the only time new clothes are nexus are weekends, holidays, and summer break, which is a lot less clothes than the entire school year. Clothes can often be used to define social statuses, but if there are no different clothes, people will have to rely on personality rather than the outfit they are wearing. In schools, some students are poor while others are rich. Poor students may have scholarships in order to afford school and have ragged clothes, while rich students may be supported by very wealthy parents and have expensive, fancy clothes. These completely different types of clothes make a huge difference in their popularity at school. Instead of comparing each others clothes, students can compare each others personality and intelligence, which makes a much larger difference. Although you argue that school uniforms destroy individuality, there really isn't really a way to express yourself using clothes. Clothing is only something you wear and, in no way, can be used to define yourself. You also insist that school uniforms create robot-like unity and decrease independence and creativity, but this is not accurate at all. Uniforms cannot affect the way you think, except for in productivity and usefulness. I also do not understand how wearing the same uniform creates "robots", because "robots" are defined as 'a machine resembling a human being and able to replicate certain human movements and functions automatically', but simply looking the same does not force them to somehow act the same. And since you also agree that uniforms do not affect how someone acts; this proves that uniforms will not harm how someone acts. Your turn, pro!

    • https://www.debate.org/debates/School-Uniforms-Should-not-be-Required/5/
  • PRO

    I accept, and will be arguing that there should be school...

    should there be school uniforms

    I accept, and will be arguing that there should be school uniforms for... This seems to be undefined. I will argue that there should be school uniforms for sports teams.

    • https://www.debate.org/debates/should-there-be-school-uniforms/1/
  • CON

    The earlier they get up the more tired they would be...

    School uniforms should be banned

    Decreased time In the morning spent getting dressed Women spend nearly one year of their lives choosing what to wear in the morning[1]. This is way too much. With school uniforms it's simple you put on your skirt and blazer and head out the door. Getting ready in the morning can take up to an hour[2] minutes meaning students have to wake up earlier to get ready. The earlier they get up the more tired they would be meaning they would focus less in class. If their alarm doesn't go off they can be late for school meaning more class time. This may not be completely ended by the use of school uniforms, but it would certainly reduce the numbers. Uniforms are safe When walking home from school students wearing the wrong colour at the wrong time can get injured or killed. People have also been robbed for wearing expensive clothing(Jordan's, Gucci etc.). This wouldn't happen to students in uniforms because these misinterpretations wouldn't occur to someone in a shirt and dress pants[3]. Citation [1]http://www.telegraph.co.uk... [2]https://today.yougov.com... [3]M. Sue Stanley, "School Uniforms and Safety," Education and Urban Society, Aug.

    • https://www.debate.org/debates/School-uniforms-should-be-banned/7/
  • PRO

    3)(4) A leader of the study, David L. Brunsma, PhD, found...

    School uniforms should be banned

    Secondly, school uniforms don"t improve academic behavior. According to a national wide study of 10th graders conducted by the Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University discovered that "no effects of uniforms on absenteeism, behavioral problems, or substance use on campus" and "no effects" on "pro-school attitudes, academic preparedness, and peer attitudes toward school." (3)(4) A leader of the study, David L. Brunsma, PhD, found a "negative effect of uniforms on academic achievement" and that there is unchanged performance in children that attend elementary and middle schools. (3) Additionally, a 2009 study concluded that "no significant effects of school uniforms on performance on second grade reading and mathematics examinations, as well as on 10th-grade reading, mathematics, science, and history examinations... [I]n many of the specifications, the results are actually negative." (5) Based on the research, this demonstrates that school uniforms are ineffective towards curriculum activities and can be harmful to the education system. Thus, they are unnecessary to the learning environment. Sources: (3) David L. Brunsma, The School Uniform Movement and What It Tells Us about American Education: A Symbolic Crusade, 2004 (4) David L. Brunsma and Kerry A. Rockquemore, "Effects of Student Uniforms on Attendance, Behavior Problems, Substance Use, and Academic Achievement," Journal of Educational Research, Sep./Oct. 1998 (5) Ryan Yeung, "Are School Uniforms a Good Fit?: Results from the ECLS-K and the NELS," Educational Policy, Nov.

    • https://www.debate.org/debates/School-uniforms-should-be-banned/7/
  • CON

    When buying uniforms for the school, you cannot assume...

    School Uniforms are a good idea

    I, for one, do not think that school uniforms are a good idea for the follwing reasons: 1) Uniforms cost money. Obviously, school uniforms, like any other type of clothing, can be very costly. Where will the money come from? The taxpayers (some of which won't even benefit from the uniforms)? State funding? Either way you go with this, someone is going to have to pay for something that they probably don't even want. 2) Students come in all shapes and sizes. It's quite noticable that today's students are all very different in size. When buying uniforms for the school, you cannot assume that one size fits all. You'd have to size the students, order the uniforms, and then return them if they don't fit right. It's a continious, costly, cycle. Also, what if a student is irregular in size? What if they are super tall and really skinny? Then they would have to be taylored to the needs of that one student. 3) Students need to be unique. Having every student in a school dress the same way is like saying 'hey, you're not allowed to be different. You have to dress like everyone else because it's easier that way.' There's a certain thrill that teenagers get when they buy new outfit and where it to school for the first time. That thrill could potentially be threatened by instating a school uniform policy in schools. Having these uniforms is pretty much censoring the real world from them. Students need to understand and accept the fact that some people are different, and they have no chance of learning that when everyone in their school dresses the same. That concludes my opening statment.

    • https://www.debate.org/debates/School-Uniforms-are-a-good-idea/2/
  • CON

    Bring a sense of uniformity & unity among pupils 5. ......

    School Uniforms Should not be Required

    School uniforms are necessary because 1. Enable children to focus on their school work as opposed to what type of clothes they wear 2. They put all children at the same level as socioeconomic status is not apparent from the uniforms they where since they are all the same. 3. Removes the status symbol associated with flashy clothes removing peer pressures of that kind 4. Bring a sense of uniformity & unity among pupils 5. Good for security as you can identify kids who should be at a particular school 6. Save parents money especially those coming fr poor families 7. Uniforms also enable students to get ready for school faster as they don't have much of a fashion statement to make, just put on your uniform and you are ready to go 8. Uniforms enable students to self express in a way that is relevant to their learning i.e through extra curriculum activities, their talents 9. Enable children to make friends based on personality and character instead of what you wear 10. In a way wearing school uniforms reduces bullying since some of the bullying comes from what other children wear, so if clothing is standardized there is no bullying based on that

    • https://www.debate.org/debates/School-Uniforms-Should-not-be-Required/1/